Melvin Trotter
The Geography of An Execution
Before 2025, Florida’s previous modern-era record for executions in a year was eight in 1984 and 2014. The modern era represents the time since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976, after a 1972 U.S. Supreme Court decision halted it. The name Gregg will forevermore be linked to death.
Florida's governor in 1984 was Bob Graham (serving 1979–1987), and the governor in 2014 was Rick Scott (serving 2011–2019).
Florida has entered a totally new and challenging era with the current Governor, Ron DeSantis, who seems to be focused on “delivering justice to the victims” and “closure for the families.” This is a promise which he is destined to be unable to deliver on because, quite simply, executions only create more victims and the closure is really only a form of revenge which merely leaves a bitter taste in one’s mouth. The vast majority of family members of murder victims that I have talked with say that they receive no closure, and that there will always be a hole in their hearts and minds that death covets.
“Rather than pausing after the deadliest execution year in state history, Florida has begun the new year exactly where it left off. This is not about excusing violence. It is about whether Florida will continue treating executions as routine, despite the risk of irreversible error and the deep harm this system causes to victims’ families, corrections staff, courts and communities.”
FADP-Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty Official Statement
Gov. Ron DeSantis set a new state record for most executions in a year with 19 death warrants issued in 2025. He appears to be keeping his 2025 Florida inmate execution marathon going with a second death warrant issued under his Sharpie pen this month alone.
DeSantis signed a death warrant on Friday, Jan. 23 for Melvin Trotter, 65, convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death for strangling and stabbing Virgie Langford in Palmetto in 1986.
Trotter is scheduled to die by lethal injection Feb. 24, two weeks after the execution of Ronald Palmer Heath.
Trotter was sentenced to death in the June 1986 murder of Virgie Langford, 70, who was found by a truck driver on the floor at the back of Langford’s Grocery Store in Palmetto, according to court documents.
Florida and DeSantis set the new record by putting to death two inmates each month from May through December, 2025. Last year, Florida executed four times as many inmates as any other state in the nation.
The machinery of death has no brakes. But it does have a geographical engine.
Per Capita Execution Rate by State (2025)
Executions per 1 Million Residents
State | Executions | Population (millions) | Per Capita Rate
-----------------|------------|------------------------|-----------------
Florida | 19 | 23.3 | 0.82
Alabama | 5 | 5.1 | 0.98
South Carolina | 5 | 5.4 | 0.93
Texas | 5 | 30.5 | 0.16
Tennessee | 3 | 7.2 | 0.42
Mississippi | 2 | 2.9 | 0.69
Oklahoma | 2 | 4.0 | 0.50
Arizona | 2 | 7.4 | 0.27
Indiana | 2 | 6.9 | 0.29
Louisiana | 1 | 4.6 | 0.22
Missouri | 1 | 6.2 | 0.16“She had suffered a large abdominal wound which resulted in disembowelment; there were a total of seven stab wounds,” a 1990 Florida Supreme Court opinion that upheld Trotter’s conviction said. “She told the driver that she had been stabbed and robbed. Several hours after the surgery for her wounds, the victim went into cardiac arrest and died.”
Melvin Trotter of Manatee County received the death sentence, twice, for fatally stabbing Langford, 70, during the robbery of her convenience store. The Florida Supreme Court awarded Trotter a resentencing after it was found the court mishandled aggravating factors of his case. He was sentenced to death a second time in 1993. The court reaffirmed the death sentence in 1996.
Trotter was on house arrest for a previous burglary conviction when prosecutors said he waited outside Langford’s Grocery Store in Palmetto on June 16, 1986, for the last customer to leave. He confronted Langford, the owner, and stabbed her seven times with a butcher knife before taking $100 to buy drugs. A truck driver found her there.
Langford had “a large abdominal wound that resulted in disembowelment,” according to a summary by state Attorney General James Uthmeier. Hours after her surgery, Langford died of cardiac arrest.
Langford was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to death in May 1987. He was also found guilty of burglary, robbery without a gun and robbery with a gun or deadly weapon, for which he was sentenced to 17 years in prison.
Attorneys for Trotter filed multiple appeals, pointing to Trotter’s teenage years diagnosis of mental disability. Under Florida law, the death sentence may not be constitutionally imposed on an “intellectually disabled defendant.” Florida state prosecutors said in 2005 that a number of evaluations over thirty years showed Trotter’s intelligence as in the average range.
Trotter is a child that is the result of rape. He grewup fatherless and suffered from emotional deprivation and physical abuse fromhis alcoholic mother. He was placed into foster care when he was nine years old. While in foster care, his foster father was placed in jail for aggravated battery and he was raised solely by his foster mother. Trotter claims that his foster care was abusive and unhealthy. The only close familial relationship Trotter ever had was with his sister. While Trotter was in his late teens his sister was violently killed by gunshot.
Trotter was interviewed by a clinical psychiatrist after being arrested. The psychiatrist concluded that Trotter had an I.Q. in the range of 72. He reported that Trotter is a slow learner, has impaired common sense, and is unable to plan or think ahead and is also unable to consider the consequences of his behavior. The psychiatrist described Trotter as someone who would not become violent unless he was in a situation which he perceived to be violent. He also noted that Trotter’s sense of reality could be distorted and his inhibition reduced due to his cocaine use.
Trotter’s appeals were denied in 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, and 2018, Uthmeier said (Florida Attorney General).
Florida has carried out 125 executions since GREGG.
Three states — Alabama, South Carolina, and Florida — had the highest execution rates per capita in America.
Texas falls near the bottom per capita despite its raw total, showing how population size masks frequency.
The Deep South dominates both in total executions and execution rate.
Nearly three out of every four executions in the United States occurred in former Confederate states.
Melvin Trotter’s case is not an outlier — it is the blueprint. A brutal crime, a lifetime of litigation, arguments about intellectual disability, a childhood shaped by violence, poverty, and loss, and then, after decades of being processed by the courts, a governor’s Sharpie signature that turns a human life into a date on a calendar.
I have spent years talking with the families of the murdered and the families of the condemned, and I have yet to meet the execution that delivered the closure politicians keep promising. In fact, I have spent the final hours of an executed man’s life with him.
What I have seen is what the numbers now prove. Nineteen executions in a single year. The fastest pace in Florida’s modern history. The highest per-capita killing rates clustered in the Deep South. Nearly three out of every four executions carried out in the states of the old Confederacy.
Since Gregg, Florida has put 125 human beings to death, and it is now doing it with a rhythm that makes the extraordinary routine. Trotter’s scheduled execution is not just about one man — it is about a system that runs on geography, politics, and the illusion that killing heals. I lived inside that system. I have watched men walk to their deaths. And what Florida is showing the country right now is not strength, not justice, and not closure — it is how normal state killing has become.
OR, you can help me to continue this work by buying me a cup of coffee! Just click the image below!
OR, help us to work towards abolishing the death penalty for good! Click the below image!
At any rate, thank you for being here!